Savvy Vegetarian Home Page veggies
Support For A Sustainable Vegetarian Lifestyle
Savvy Vegetarian Navbar

"To be a vegetarian is to disagree---to disagree with the course of things today. Starvation, world hunger, cruelty, waste, wars---we must make a statement against these things. Vegetarianism is my statement. And I think it's a strong one."

Isaac Bashevis Singer


FREE Report! Ten Tips for Beginning Vegetarians

    What's a Vegetarian?
  • Why Be a Vegetarian?
  • Vegan or Not?
  • Resources

Free Vegetarian Life Coaching:

Complete our vegetarian lifestyle survey, and get 30 minutes phone consultation with Coach Judy Kingsbury


FREE Expert Advice!

Answers to your questions on all things vegetarian

Ask the Savvy Vegetarian


Savvy Vegetarian Life Coaching:

Whatever the challenges in becoming vegetarian, life coaching will increase your confidence, dramatically shorten the learning curve, and smooth the bumps in the road.


Savvy Vegetarian Resource Guide:

Send Us a Resource!


Genetically Modified Food News: Farmers, GM Products, the EU & the WTO

Savvy Vegetarian News

Vol. 1, Issue 3, May 2003

Back To Newsletter Index


The following genetically modified food information is taken from an article in the Farm Journal, Mar, 2003 Issue, "Iraq Stymies EU Case", by Jane Fullerton

The article is a discussion of a pending US decision whether to file suit with the World Trade Organization (WTO) over a European Union (EU) moratorium on approvals of genetically modified (GM) food products. The decision has been postponed because of the war with Iraq, because White House officials don't want to further alienate EU allies.

According to the Farm Journal article, there are presently 18 GM products approved by the European Union, with the last approval issued in 1998. Approval of 13 other GM products is apparently being held up by the June, 1999 EU moratorium on GM products

The article quotes Clyde Preskowitz, a former Commerce Department official: "If we go ahead with this case, the consumer reaction in Europe...is going to be such that not only are you not going to sell $300 million of GM foods, but you're going to sell $400 million or $500 million less of things that we already sell. Because there's going to be a tremendous backlash against American goods, and it won't just be food."

U.S. ag groups, and members of congress who are in favor of the WTO suit, have expressed dismay at such nay-saying. The Farm Journal article quotes Ron Gaskill of the American Farm Bureau Federation. "We feel as if, from a farmer's perspective, our back is against the wall." Gaskell goes on to say, "U.S. farmers really don't have a lot of faith that a WTO decision would be complied with. Certainly if you look at the beef hormone case of a few years ago, [the Europeans] did not comply with that adverse ruling."

According to Ms. Fullerton's article, the beef strategy was supposed to isolate the beef hormone ban in Europe, but it didn't work. She reports that Philip Seng, president and CEO of the U.S. Meat Export Federation, estimates that European-style hormone rules have spread to countries with 40% of the world's beef-eating consumers.

In closing, Ms. Fullerton again quotes Gaskell. He expresses the hope that a biotech case would allow for retaliatory tariffs on imports from the EU. "If we don't take the case, we don't have any remedy," he says. "We sit here...losing more than $1 billion in sales, to markets that we really, absolutely need."

Editorial Comments:
I doubt that retaliatory tariffs against the EU would do anything positive. In the past, that kind of effort has only increased hatred of the U.S.

Those in favor of filing suit with the WTO over the EU moratorium are ignoring a cardinal rule of marketing: You Can't Corral Your Customers. If they think for a moment that Europeans can be forced to eat GMO products if they don't want to, they're a few bushels short of a load!

It seems that American farmers are truly between a rock and a hard place when it comes to GMO. On one hand, they are almost bound hand and foot by the manufacturers of GMO seed. If they try to follow an alternative route, they are attacked on all sides. Take for example, Monsanto's large, successful monetary suits against farmers whose non-GMO seed is polluted by GMO crops. On the other hand, Europe doesn't want GMO products, and American farmers caught in the GMO machine are helpless. Farming has ever been a hard life, but never more than right now for conventional farmers.

Please contact your elected representatives often and ask them to oppose the WTO suit against the European GMO moratorium, and/or to act on behalf of any particular issue you support or oppose. Here's where to find your congressional reps and senators:

http://www.senate.gov

http://www.house.gov

And vote with your feet - buy organic, non-GMO products!


Index: Savvy Vegetarian News

Vol. 1, Issue 3, May , 2003

Article: Congress Weakens Organic Standards. Reprint of a series on Fieldale Farms attempt to subvert the integrity of the Organic Standards Act. Author Ken Roseboro is a journalist who has written extensively about genetically modified foods, GMO testing, non-GMO certification, and identity preservation. His articles have appeared in leading agricultural and food industry magazines. Ken is publisher and editor of The Non-GMO Source: http://www.non-gmosource.com

Ask The Savvy Vegetarian: How To Eat Beans Without Gas

Quick and Easy Recipe: Quinoa (keen-wah) Pilaf

Book Review: "The Food Revolution", by John Robbins


Click here to ask questions or send contributions to Savvy Vegetarian News.

Subscribe to Savvy Vegetarian News:
Email: [email protected] : Subject "subscribe"


Savvy Vegetarian Home Savvy Vegetarian Home Savvy Vegetarian Recipes Savvy Vegetarian Newsletter Savvy Vegetarian Life Coaching Ask The Savvy Vegetarian Savvy Blog Savvy Vegetarian Resources Savvy Vegetarian Contact Us